Buy It Once The cheapest product is the one you buy once.

About

Buy It Once grades household goods by how long they actually last, one production era at a time. This page covers who writes it and how the scoring works. The money has a page of its own, generated from the same rows the links are built from, and every correction is logged in public.

Eras, not brands

A brand is a name, and names get sold. Pyrex is neither good nor bad — pre-1998 Corning-era Pyrex is borosilicate, current US Pyrex is tempered soda-lime, and those are different products wearing one logo. So the unit that gets graded here is the product-era, and every grade names its period. When an era boundary is crossed, both sides stay in the catalogue and are graded separately.

Cost per year, not price

A $350 boot that lasts twenty years costs $17.50 a year. A $170 boot that lasts four costs $42.50. The expensive boot is the cheap one, and the headline number on every record says so. Price is deliberately excluded from the score itself — cheapness is not quality — and shown beside it instead, so you can weigh it yourself.

How scoring works

Per era, never a brand average. The composite:

Score weights. The rubric is also restated on every record.
InputWeightWhat it reads
Material durability40%The weakest material in the load path, not the one on the box.
Owner reports25%Check-ins, failures, and the longest documented service life.
Warranty terms20%The written clause, weighted by documented claim outcomes.
Repairability15%Parts availability and whether a repair path is documented.

The score is recomputed from each row's own evidence on every read — never stored and served back — so a grade change moves the number everywhere at once and the listing page cannot disagree with the record. Health is graded separately and kept out of the composite entirely: a product can be built to outlive you and still be something you would rather not sleep on, and averaging the two lets one hide the other.

The rule about sources

A user-visible assertion that cannot name the document behind it is a bug, not a row. Every claim carries its source; the linter fails the build if anything unsourced exists; and where a record's grades were seeded from research notes and not yet re-verified, the record says so on its face rather than hiding it. The research desk holds the warranty watch and the clause archive.

Community testimony

Owner reports are quoted at the consent tier on file: linked — a public post, quoted minimally and linked; asked — we requested permission before quoting or naming; submitted — sent to us directly, on the submitter's terms. Reader votes never move a score. Only documented reports do.

Contact

Corrections are the most useful thing you can send. If your work changes a grade, it gets logged with credit on the corrections page.