Buy It Once The cheapest product is the one you buy once.

The anti-canon

Products and promises that were buy-it-for-life and are not any more, kept with dates and sources rather than as a grievance list. And kept in both directions: when a brand improves it is recorded with the same rigour, or this page is just somewhere to be rude about companies.

Guarantees that were cut

From the warranty watch, which holds the archived page text on both sides of the change. Each row is a promise that was narrowed, not a promise someone felt was narrowed.

Jan 2017 A → C

Craftsman

Was Lifetime hand-tool warranty, over-the-counter exchange, no receipt

Now Revised limited warranty; the legacy terms are honoured only on Sears-era tools

the terms ↗

Apr 2018 B → C

Dr. Martens

Was Lifetime For Life guarantee: any component failing from normal wear covered to owner's natural life (£20 admin fee, non-transferable)

Now For Life range discontinued; mainline reverts to 1-year limited warranty against manufacturing defects only

the terms ↗

Apr 2018 A → D

Dr. Martens

Was 'For Life' range, lifetime

Now Discontinued; replaced by non-guaranteed line

ongoing B → C?

Flint & Tinder

Was 10-year hoodie guarantee

Now Claim-friction reports

ongoing A → B

JanSport

Was Lifetime warranty, marketed without qualification

Now Limited lifetime in the US/Canada; 30-year limited in the EU; authorised dealers only

the terms ↗

Feb 2018 A → C

L.L.Bean

Was Lifetime, any condition

Now 1 year + receipt

2013 A → B-

REI

Was Lifetime, no questions

Now 1 year (members)

Eras that graded down

Both eras are in the catalogue and graded separately, so the claim carries the two numbers behind it. A shift naming an era we have not graded is not listed: an undated, unscored assertion that something got worse is the kind of claim this site exists not to make.

2003 / 2018 -18 points

Dr. Martens: the leather changed, then the promise did

Mainline production moved offshore in 2003 and the leather spec moved down the scale with it. The 'For Life' guaranteed range — thicker spec, lifetime backing — was discontinued on 1 April 2018. Two changes, one direction.

2009–2018 95 → 2003– · offshore 77

2017 / 2019 / 2023 -15 points

Craftsman: the name outlived the promise, twice

Sears sold the brand to Stanley Black & Decker in January 2017 for $525 million plus deferred payments, and kept a royalty-free licence to the name until 2032 — so two companies now sell Craftsman tools. Stanley opened a Fort Worth plant in 2019 to make it American again, and closed it in March 2023. The lifetime warranty that made the name is honoured on legacy tools and is not the warranty on anything sold today.

pre-2017 · Sears era 95 → 2023– · Stanley Black & Decker 80

2002–2020s -12 points

Stanley: the steel held — the intent changed

The material never moved: it's stainless then and now. What changed after the 2002 sale and the 2020 viral turn is what the product is for — a 30-year jobsite tool became a colorway on a release calendar. Materials can't tell you everything; eras can.

vintage · pre-offshore 81 → viral era · 2020– 69

1998 -7 points

Pyrex: the company was sold, and the glass changed

Corning spun off the consumer line in 1998. US-market Pyrex has been tempered soda-lime since; the vintage stock and the EU line stayed borosilicate. Same logo, different material — the care rules changed and the lifespan followed.

pre-1998 (boro-era hunt) 84 → 1998– (soda-lime era) 77

1986 -7 points

KitchenAid: the Hobart question

Hobart sold the brand in 1986 — the era line collectors still use. The current machines remain among the most repairable countertop appliances sold new; the argument is whether that clears the bar the Hobart era set. Both are in the catalog; pick your era.

vintage · pre-1986 Hobart 81 → current production 74

Improved — same rigour, other direction

Nothing documented moving the other way yet. That is a gap in the research, not a finding: brands do improve, and when one does it belongs here.