Research
Everything on this site is an assertion someone can check. This page is the audit trail: which sources we use and what each one is actually authoritative for, which promises have changed, and how much of the corpus is still unread.
The warranty watch
A withdrawn guarantee is the change a brand never announces. Marketing pages stay warm while the terms page changes underneath.
| Brand | Was | Now | Changed | Grade |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Craftsman | Lifetime hand-tool warranty, over-the-counter exchange, no receipt | Revised limited warranty; the legacy terms are honoured only on Sears-era tools | Jan 2017 | A → C src |
| Dr. Martens | Lifetime For Life guarantee: any component failing from normal wear covered to owner's natural life (£20 admin fee, non-transferable) | For Life range discontinued; mainline reverts to 1-year limited warranty against manufacturing defects only | Apr 2018 | B → C src |
| Dr. Martens | 'For Life' range, lifetime | Discontinued; replaced by non-guaranteed line | Apr 2018 | A → D |
| Flint & Tinder | 10-year hoodie guarantee | Claim-friction reports | ongoing | B → C? |
| JanSport | Lifetime warranty, marketed without qualification | Limited lifetime in the US/Canada; 30-year limited in the EU; authorised dealers only | ongoing | A → B src |
| L.L.Bean | Lifetime, any condition | 1 year + receipt | Feb 2018 | A → C |
| REI | Lifetime, no questions | 1 year (members) | 2013 | A → B- |
| Briggs & Riley | Lifetime repair, incl. airline damage | Holding | — | A src |
| Darn Tough | Unconditional lifetime, no receipt | Unchanged | — | A src |
| Patagonia | Ironclad Guarantee, repair-first | Holding | — | A src |
Source registry
Trust tiers are scoped. A brand's own warranty page is tier A for “what the terms say” and would be tier D for “whether claims get honoured” — those are different questions and one source rarely answers both.
| Source | Kind | Tier | Authoritative for | Docs | Facts |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand warranty terms ↗ | brand_doc | a | Authoritative for what the terms say, not for whether claims are honoured. | 47 | 71 |
| Corelle product and FAQ pages ↗ | brand_doc | a | Vitrelle composition and care guidance from the maker. Tier A for what the product is; tier D for how long it lasts. | 0 | 0 |
| Herman Miller warranty pages ↗ | brand_doc | a | What Herman Miller warrants. Tier A for the terms only. | 0 | 1 |
| JanSport warranty pages ↗ | brand_doc | a | What JanSport warrants, per region. The US and EU pages differ materially, which is itself the finding. | 0 | 1 |
| Miele warranty and product pages ↗ | brand_doc | a | What Miele warrants, in its own words. Tier A for the terms; tier D for whether claims are honoured. | 0 | 1 |
| SEC EDGAR filings ↗ | web | a | Acquisitions, sale prices and terms, as filed. Authoritative for what a transaction WAS; says nothing about what happened to the product afterwards. | 0 | 2 |
| Steelcase warranty pages ↗ | brand_doc | a | What Steelcase warrants. Tier A for the terms only. | 0 | 0 |
| AllAmerican.org manufacturing investigations ↗ | web | b | Country-of-manufacture investigations, including figures obtained directly from brands. Authoritative for where things are made; a single outlet, so corroboration matters. | 0 | 2 |
| Manual research: maker | web | b | Entered by hand from a named document. | 17 | 17 |
| Manual research: manual-research | web | b | Entered by hand from a named document. | 53 | 194 |
| eBay Browse API ↗ | api | b | Authoritative for what is currently listed and at what price. Says nothing about whether a listing is the era we graded — that judgement is ours, and it is recorded separately. | 0 | 0 |
| Buy It Once design prototype (Jul 2026) | manual | c | Editorial seed: product-era selection, takes, and provisional grades. Authoritative for what we intend to publish, NOT for any external fact it restates. | 0 | 7 |
| Manual research: wikipedia ↗ | web | c | Entered by hand from a named document. | 28 | 33 |
| r/BIFL ↗ | c | First-hand owner reports: longevity, failure modes, repair and warranty-claim outcomes. Anecdotal by nature — a single comment is tier-low evidence; corroboration across threads is what raises it. | 4984 | 71 | |
| r/BuyFromEU ↗ | c | First-hand owner reports: longevity, failure modes, repair and warranty-claim outcomes. Anecdotal by nature — a single comment is tier-low evidence; corroboration across threads is what raises it. | 12950 | 13 | |
| r/BuyItForLife ↗ | c | First-hand owner reports: longevity, failure modes, repair and warranty-claim outcomes. Anecdotal by nature — a single comment is tier-low evidence; corroboration across threads is what raises it. | 1136910 | 14717 | |
| r/BuyMyContent ↗ | c | First-hand owner reports: longevity, failure modes, repair and warranty-claim outcomes. Anecdotal by nature — a single comment is tier-low evidence; corroboration across threads is what raises it. | 43 | 0 | |
| Research skill: mine-reports | skill | d | Model-proposed findings, unverified. Authoritative for nothing on its own — a starting point for an editor, and a pointer at the primary source that would settle it. | 0 | 148 |
Pipeline
Documents become claims; claims become prose. Nothing is published until independent sources — not word count — clear the gate.
Documents read2880
1142600 still queued
Claims8244
457 disputed
Entries3
of 5111 started
In review448
awaiting a human
Recent corrections
- 2026-07-19 lecreuset — Stoneware term rewritten to show the 5-vs-10-year conflict in the maker's own documents (CR-LC1)
- 2026-07-18 osprey — Terms-verification flag added pending a re-read of the All Mighty guarantee
- 2026-07-16 kaidnow — Note clarified: the sacrificial worm gear is design intent — the argument is recorded in both directions
- 2026-07-02 sawyer — Freeze-failure warning promoted into the buying notes
- 2026-06-14 darntough — Warranty grade held at A after three more documented claim outcomes — reported by u/•••, r/BuyItForLife