Buy It Once Shortlist

Oneida Oneida stainless flatware, Sherrill-made, before 2005 (used)

1961–2005 · Sherrill, New York · Stainless steel flatware · made in Sherrill, New York, USA

Yard-sale stainless that looks the same after thirty years of daily use. Pieces marked as made in the USA are the ones from the factory sold in 2005.

+ shortlist

Score 81/100 confidence medium · 2 sources
Cost per year $0.30/yr $15 over 50 yr
Warranty — n/a (secondhand)
Health A weakest: Stainless steel
Footprint C/A making it / using it
Expected life 50 yr median service life
Status vintage

Materials

Every part that takes load. The weakest one sets the grade.

MaterialDurabilityHealthEnv (make/use)Typical life
Stainless steel weakest link
Dents are cosmetic; in bottles, the vacuum seam is the one weak point.
A A C/A decades

Warranty

— n/a (secondhand)

No warranty on used flatware, and the company that made it no longer runs the factory.

Not graded, because secondhand goods carry no terms.

We haven't checked these terms against the maker's current page yet.

Where to buy

No offers recorded for this era. This one is a secondhand hunt — see the secondhand desk.

+ shortlist Line it up against the others you're considering, by total cost and cost per year.

Our price ($15) is the typical price we graded against. The shop's price and stock may differ.

Other eras of Oneida

Same name, different era. Check which one you're looking at.

Oneida · 2021– · Lenox · contract-made

Michelangelo 18/10 flatware, 20-piece set, current

Oneida Michelangelo 18/10 stainless flatware, one five-piece place setting

$7.50/yr $224.95

82/100 warranty B Not stated on the product page; Oneida no longer manufactures in the US steady

A 1965 pattern in 18/10 steel with a lifetime warranty for the original owner. It is no longer made in Sherrill, and the page does not say where it is made.

full record → + shortlist unverified

Compare

Something wrong with this record?

Tell us. A person reads every report.

A broken link, a changed warranty, a grade you can show is wrong, or the item failed on you. If your report changes a grade, the correction log says so.

Cite this record

Oneida Oneida stainless flatware, Sherrill-made, before 2005 (used) (1961–2005 · Sherrill, New York) — score 81/100, warranty —, health A. Buy It Once, retrieved 2026. https://buy-it-once.com/product/oneida-sherrill