Buy It Once The cheapest product is the one you buy once.

Rankings

Every product-era on the site in one table — click a column to sort it — and the same rows plotted against price below. The aisles answer "what should I buy for this job"; this page answers the other question, which is where the durability per dollar actually is.

All (5+) Kitchen & DiningClothing & ShoesHome & FurnitureOutdoors & GardenTools & HardwareBags & TravelElectronics & AppliancesKids & Baby

5 product-eras in Tools & Hardware, ordered by score. W = warranty · H = health · ENV = footprint to make / to use.
Product Era Price $/yr Yrs Score W H Env Status
Hand tools — Sears era (used)Craftsman pre-2017 · Sears era $30 $0.50/yr 60 yr 95 A A A/A vintage
16 oz claw hammerEstwing Rockford, USA · continuous $38 $0.95/yr 40 yr 91 B- A C/A steady
Bullet vise (USA era)Wilton vintage · pre-import $150 $2.50/yr 60 yr 81 — A A/B vintage
Bailey No. 5 planeStanley vintage · pre-WWII pattern $45 $0.75/yr 60 yr 81 — A A/A vintage
Hand tools — currentCraftsman 2023– · Stanley Black & Decker $40 $2.00/yr 20 yr 80 C A C/A falling

The price map

One dot per product-era. Higher is a better score, further right is more expensive, so the dots up in the left-hand corner are the ones that last longest per dollar. Hollow dots are bought secondhand — their price is an estimate of what the used market asks, not a shelf price. Price runs on a square-root scale, because the catalogue spans $14 to $1,300 and a linear axis would pile four fifths of it into the left tenth of the plot.

rising steady falling vintage, bought used median price

0 25 50 75 100 $10 $30 $100 median $40 price, square-root scale → score ↑ Craftsman Hand tools — Sears era (used) — score 95, $30, $0.50/yr Estwing 16 oz claw hammer — score 91, $38, $0.95/yr Wilton Bullet vise (USA era) — score 81, $150, $2.50/yr Stanley Bailey No. 5 plane — score 81, $45, $0.75/yr Craftsman Hand tools — current — score 80, $40, $2.00/yr Craftsman Estwing Stanley
Every dot links to its record. The named dots are the cheapest per year of those scoring 80 or better.